Testing in-store fixtures saves further investment

Toy brand maximizes marketing ROI with test-and-learn approach

Holidays are a peak selling season for this Alloy customer, whose toys are known as the gold standard in early childhood play. They invested in an in-store fixture for one of their newest product categories in hopes of driving sales during such a critical time period.

The fixture was installed in ~150 stores of one of their retailers, out of a total ~250 retailer stores that sold the category. It cost $500 per store, representing a $75K total investment for the promotion.

Key results

  • $860K marketing spend saved and reinvested


  • Experiments
  • Automatic retailer point-of-sale data integration
  • Custom group creation


The marketing team set up an Experiment comparing the sales performance of the category in the stores that had the fixture installed (test) vs. the stores that did not (control). They learned there was no noticeable difference in sales – the fixtures provided hardly any lift to those stores. 

Puzzle Rack Experiment Dashboard

Based on these results, the brand decided to cancel planned rollouts of the same display at another retailer in the spring.

Instead of spending $500 per store to install the same fixture and receive no return at another retailer, the brand can make better use of that budget on other initiatives. Looking at just one of their key retailers, this insight from Alloy software unlocked about $860K of marketing spend.


Related resources

Customer Stories

Tile’s CEO on navigating the pain points of modern supply and demand

CJ Prober and other consumer goods leaders share insights into product line strategy, when to approach retailers and addressing unauthorized resellers.


The 5 keys to success with retail buyers — from a Walmart Supplier of the Year

What is the secret sauce that earns a company Walmart Supplier of the Year? Hear from Joe Botts how and why the Moose Toys team...

Keep reading
Customer Stories

Alloy selected by Ferrero USA for digital supply chain management

Ferrero USA implements innovative supply chain management solution that delivers end-to-end visibility, insight and action.